Poster for Five Star Final
Five Star Final:
A Study in the Radicalization of News
Five Star Final is a film that showcases
an extreme example of when journalism ethics go out the window.
Joseph Randall is the editor of the New
York Gazette newspaper. In his attempts to make the paper more legitimate, the
number of copies sold has dropped dramatically. Thus, his bosses come to him
with an idea on how to increase the number of copies. The simple answer is
their idea amounts to pure sensationalism.
They want to do a retrospective on an older murder case from over twenty years ago. They task a reportor who is disguised as a priest to go to their home and get any information. Nancy Voorhees (the killer) and her husband Michael Townsend belief he is a priest with relation to the church their daughter Nancy is getting married at. So, they give the fake priest Isopod a photo thinking it would be used for marriage purposes. However, the next day the find the retrospective and photo plastered on the front page of the paper.
The scandal explodes and, in the aftermath, both Nancy and Michael kill themselves. Leaving Nancy and her fiancé Phillip Weeks furious at the Gazette. Randall himself already reflected and said he's not releasing any more issues to right in front of the higher ups. Nancy confronts the group and screams "why did you kill my mother." She even attempts to shoot Randall before Phillip stops her and tells the Gazette to never write anything about their family ever again. The final shot sees the suicide article being swallowed by the rain, showing that the public is fully against the paper and their sensationalism failed.
The film is of course entertainment first and a allegory second. However the ideas about journalism have grounds in history and even in the real world today. One of those was the Penny Press Era. The idea of selling copies for cheap to everyone to turn a profit. That was all the higher ups at the paper were worried about. They wanted to be the highest selling paper through any means necessary. No matter the effects on the people which brings up an ethical issue.
The goal of the journalism to inform the people and also to produce news that gets eyes on the newspaper. However posing as someone else and breaking into homes are obviously not included in that. The other less obvious issue is the retrospective isn't newsworthy. It's not relevant to anyone any there are more timely issues that could have been covered. There's been a implied barrier between a journalist and the person they're doing a story. It's always why most interviews aren't conducted in peoples homes.
The characters often fail and these ethical considerations. Randall is seen to be pushing the story and orders Isopode to pose as a preist to obtain senstive information. It takes him until after the suicide to realize he's gone to far. Hinchcliffe and the other higher ups never really understand how what they've done is seriously damaging, and have to be shamed by Nancy to not be as braizen in their support.
The film is a entertaining time and also serves a front for the consideration of journalism ethics in the modern day. I highly recommend giving it a watch.

